50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (2024)

01of 50

Banana Muffins

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (1)

"Have made this recipe a couple times now. It truly is a HUGE HIT each time I make them! Will need to start making them in double batches!" —Ray Robinson

02of 50

Breakfast Sausage Casserole

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (2)

"I am constantly being asked for this recipe everytime I make it. So easy to put together. Best way to feed many for a stress free morning meal." —Allrecipes Member

Easy French Toast Casserole

03of 50

Baked Dijon Salmon

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (3)

"I made this tonight and it was delicious. My husband devoured it and asked when I would make it again. I made it as is. I wouldn’t change a thing." —Julie Evans

Cedar Planked Salmon

04of 50

Apple Crumble

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (4)

"The crumble came out golden and crispy. A good and simple recipe." –Yoly

Apple Tarte Tatin

05of 50

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Muffins

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (5)

"So good and moist. Just the right balance of pumpkin and chocolate." —HannahG

Homemade Pumpkin Spice

06of 50

Chicken and Stuffing Casserole

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (6)

"My husband made this and he doesn't usually cook and never makes casseroles. This was SO delicious. I'm sure if he could do it and it turned out so well this recipe must be amazing. I loooooved it. Thanks so much for sharing this recipe..." —Ash Rinebolt

07of 50

Broccoli Salad

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (7)

"So, so good! I actually like broccoli now! I made this recipe EXACTLY as stated and it is PERFECT as written." —SquirrellyGirly

08of 50

Chicken Milanese

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (8)

“Great recipe. Easy, quick, crunchy, and delish!” —Cari

Easy Arugula Salad

09of 50

Easy White Chicken Chili

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (9)

“This recipe is quick and very tasty. I like that I usually have all the ingredients on hand (with the exception of cilantro). It tasted even better the next day!” –sarahp

White Bean Chicken Chili

10of 50

Gourmet Mushroom Risotto

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (10)

"By far the best risotto I have eaten. Thank you for sharing the recipe. I thought my mother's recipe was good, but this one takes it all." —Cristian Lagarini

Instant Pot Mushroom Risotto

11of 50

Grandma's Hamburger Casserole

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (11)

"This was divine. I can't wait until dinner time tomorrow when we can eat leftovers. My husband and I will definitely make this again. Thanks for the recipe." —ShebasMom

12of 50

Homemade Beef Stew

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (12)

"I have made many stew recipes and this is hands down the winner! The combination of seasonings, especially the rosemary, knock it out of the park!" —dbellmaine

13of 50

Homemade Smash Burgers

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (13)

"Excellent! From now on, this will be the only way I'll make burgers!" —BILL

Air Fryer Sweet Potato Fries

14of 50

Juicy Roasted Chicken

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (14)

"Best roast chicken recipe ever. The smells wile roasting are intoxicating and it is the juiciest roast chicken." —Daniel White

15of 50

Baked Sweet Potatoes

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (15)

"A great alternative to oven baked french fries. Will definitely make it again!" —Woody W.

Simple Roasted Butternut Squash

16of 50

Million Dollar Spaghetti

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (16)

"I love making baked spaghetti and am always looking for different recipes to enhance the flavors. This is spot on! The cream cheese brings out a rich and creamy flavor while the pasta sauce gives it a real zing!" —Lucky

Quick and Easy Chicken Spaghetti

17of 50

Grandma's Cornbread Dressing

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (17)

"Turned out PERFECTLY. Exactly how I remember my Nanny's house smelling for every Thanksgiving and Christmas!" —Samantha Azar

Awesome and Easy Creamy Corn Casserole

18of 50

Basic Biscuits

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (18)

"EXCELLENT recipe! First time I ever made biscuits that weren't as heavy as rocks. My husband grew up on home made biscuits and thought they were as good as any he had ever eaten." —Wander'sWorld

Easy Sausage Gravy and Biscuits

19of 50

Green Beans Almondine

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (19)

"Compliments from everyone! It was delicious!!" —Joan Ford Dyer

Best Green Bean Casserole

20of 50

One Bowl Chocolate Cake

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (20)

""I make this cake all the time and my family loves it. They request it any time they get the chance to. Also, on top of that it is so easy to prepare and cook!" —Kali Hintz

Homemade Chocolate Frosting

21of 50

Oven Fried Chicken

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (21)

"Oh goodness, is this a delicious recipe. I just finished a piece of this chicken and it was fabulous – and I was eating cold leftovers.—JENMI

22of 50

Coconut Macaroons

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (22)

"It is very easy to make and tastes DELICIOUS as-is. Crispy on the outside, gooey on the outside. Didn’t hurt to dip in melted chocolate either!” —Love2bake

Simple Cake Pops

23of 50

New York-Style Cheesecake

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (23)

"“It's so versatile and I love the citrus accents. Definitely my go-to recipe!” —Cowazy22

24of 50

Perfect Flat Iron Steak

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (24)

"Best steak ever. I can't believe how good such a cheap cut could be." —TxLady2

Microwave Baked Potato

25of 50

Rosemary Braised Lamb Shanks

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (25)

“Restaurant quality. Everyone was blown away by how delicious this was." —Patty Preston Anderson

Quick and Easy Yorkshire Pudding

Oreo Balls

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (26)

"I make these for work and they vanish almost instantly with rave reviews from everyone. They're super easy to make and once you get your rhythm down they're fairly quick to make as well." —ImplosionsOfJello

Easy Oreo Truffles

27of 50

Simple Beef Stroganoff

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (27)

"Quick, easy, and tasted delicious. Perfect when you don't have much time, but need to fill hungry bellies." —alie king

Buttered Noodles

28of 50

Slow Cooker Chicken Tacos

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (28)

"This is the easiest way imaginable to make moist, flavorful shredded chicken." —Lori Bennett

Slow Cooker Carnitas

29of 50

Sausage Stuffed Jalapeños

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (29)

"These are delicious! I made them for an appetizer for Christmas dinner and they were gone in a heartbeat — I'm glad I ate one before I set them out." —Jennifer Johnston Gorohoff

Bacon-Wrapped Jalapeño Poppers

30of 50

co*cktail Meatballs

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (30)

"These were a HIT! I normally shy away from making meatballs from scratch, but this recipe was easy and quick for me." —angelglea

Pigs in a Blanket

31of 50

Banoffee Pie

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (31)

"Absolutely FABULOUS. Great texture and flavor. The family LOVED it!!!” —JennyM

Strawberry Pretzel Salad

32of 50

Cranberry Brie Bites

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (32)

"I've made these to take to a couple of parties now, and they always get rave reviews. Simple and quick to make, but so much great flavor, and they look festive." —Jeff Brown

Baked Brie in Puff Pastry

33of 50

Bacon Ranch Pasta Salad

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (33)

"I made this salad exactly as the recipe called for. It was delicious. Served it for company last night and everyone loved it, even one of the 'picky' eaters." —carrottop

Homemade Ranch Dressing

34of 50

Roasted Beets with Goat Cheese and Walnuts

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (34)

"This was a very nice, updated way to prepare beets. The flavor combination works great." —Laura

35of 50

Garlic Bread Spread

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (35)

"This is the only garlic spread I use! Have made it many times and everyone loves it. Made no changes to recipe. Thanks for sharing." —eve

Focaccia Bread

36of 50

Grandma's Hash Brown Casserole

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (36)

"I made this for a large gathering. It was easy, inexpensive, and tastes great." —Frenchie

Easy Funeral Potatoes

37of 50

Sour Cream Pound Cake

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (37)

"This is a fabulous recipe. I was trying to duplicate the pound cake that my parent's neighbor gives them every Christmas — the perfect pound cake in my book — and this is it!" —cassarugh

38of 50

To Die For Blueberry Muffins

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (38)

"I love this recipe so much! It’s easy and delicious. I’ve made it so many times that it has become a household standard to make every week." —C Pierre

Blueberry Coffee Cake

39of 50

Italian Wedding Soup

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (39)

"Made this tonight and it was WONDERFUL! The broth had a great flavor and the soup itself was nice and light." —Pat-Perry

Lemon Chicken Orzo Soup

40of 50

Baked Apples

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (40)

"I already memorized this recipe because of how simple it is. I make it whenever and it is quite good." —Nelly Krejpowicz

41of 50

Banana Banana Bread

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (41)

"It was super moist and better than most of the bananas breads I have eaten. This recipe raised the bar pretty high." —Zanstar

Banana Cake

42of 50

Butter Flaky Pie Crust

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (42)

"This was my first time ever making a pie crust and it turned out great (and beautiful). No more store-bought for me. There really is a difference!" —Evan

Thanksgiving Pies

43of 50

Cheeseburger Soup

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (43)

"A simple, hearty and great tasting meal for both kids and parents." —SamLegg

Stuffed Pepper Soup

44of 50

Homemade Vanilla Pudding

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (44)

"It’s a really easy and simple recipe and is absolutely delicious!" —Jules Jennings

45of 50

Soft Oatmeal Cookies

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (45)

"Absolutely PERFECT. Crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside. My son said that the texture on the outside reminded him of the edges of brownies!" —MrsNavarro

46of 50

Loaded Mashed Potatoes

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (46)

"This was so yummy! I upped the recipe to 20 servings for a Thanksgiving potluck and couldn't have been happier." —Heather McCarthy

47of 50

Chef John's Creamy Mushroom Soup

View Recipe

50 Five-Star Recipes We're Loving Right Now (47)

"The flavor is absolutely delicious. If you love mushrooms and want to feel like a professional chef, make this soup. Outstanding recipe, Chef John!" —gellerd

48of 50